It doesn’t require Dr. Larry Shapiro to figure out why sometimes the hardest thing can be to figure out an ending to a good story: it is hard, and even the best fall victim.
Remember the Lord of the Rings trilogy movie and the “17 endings” that so many people complained about? Hey, even the book was kind of like that. Tolkein was a great writer, but he went into overkill on ending his best works. It happens because once a writer senses the end of a story coming up, there’s a strong urge to do the: “here’s how everyone turned out in the end” thing.
Another writer who is guilty of such “ending overkill” is John Irving. I mean, I loved the World According to Garp characters as much as anyone, but do we really need to know how Garp’s newborn son turns out? That’s where the movie was superior; the story’s over after Pooh shoots Garp dead on the gymnasium floor.
There are other ways to ruin endings to good stories; I may talk about some others in a different post sometime.



